Are Employee-Recognition Programs Bad for Productivity?



    You want to motivate your workers, so you institute an employee-of-the-month program. It sounds sensible enough; by recognizing good work, you are incentivizing everyone to try harder, right?

    Unfortunately, that might not be the case.

    Research into employee recognition programs, even those that are purely symbolic, suggests that there is more complexity at play, and these programs could be negatively impacting productivity and morale.

    While workers who were previously unmotivated might strive harder with the introduction of new potential rewards, other employees who have always been intrinsically motivated might lose heart, according to a study recently accepted for publication in the journal Organization Science.

    “The common knowledge is that non-monetary awards can subtly motivate people in ways that are fundamentally different from financial reward programs, such as by increasing organizational loyalty, encouraging friendly competition or increasing employees’ self-esteem,” said Timothy Gubler, one of the study’s authors and an assistant professor at the University of California, Riverside’s School of Business Administration.

    The main drawback to implementing employee recognition programs lies in how they influence perceptions of fairness and equality in the workplace. Employees who have always shown up on time and worked hard often feel alienated by the fact that their previously unrewarded behavior is now being recognized in newly motivated employees. Moreover, employees initially motivated by the implementation of recognition programs tend to return to old habits once their eligibility for rewards lapses.

    For the study, researchers examined field data from an attendance-award program used at one of five industrial laundry plants. The program recognized all employees who came to work on time and didn’t have any unexcused absences each month, with one person receiving a $75 gift card through a random draw.

    The researchers analyzed data from all five plants both before and after the award was implemented, exploring the award’s effects on individual performance and plant productivity. They discovered that while reward-motivated employees initially responded positively to the award by cutting down on their tardiness, they reverted to their old behavior by showing up late and missing work once they lost eligibility for the award each month.

    Αποτέλεσμα εικόνας για Are Employee-Recognition Programs Bad for Productivity?

    Read more:


    Please enter your comment!
    Please enter your name here